Nick Carraway/Jay Gatsby FanFiction

Don't look into my eyes (they only serve to hypnotize)

Don't look into my eyes (they only serve to hypnotize)

F/F
M/M
Multi
G
Updated
11.04.2025
Fandom
The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald The Great Gatsby - Howland/Tysen/Kerrigan
Characters
Nick Carraway/Jay Gatsby, Jordan Baker/Myrtle Wilson, Daisy Buchanan/Tom Buchanan, Daisy Buchanan & Nick Carraway, Nick Carraway/Chester McKee, Nick Carraway/Chester McKee/Lucille McKee, Nick Carraway & Myrtle Wilson, Jordan Baker & Nick Carraway, Nick Carraway, Jay Gatsby, Jordan Baker (The Great Gatsby), Daisy Buchanan,
Tags
Alternate Universe - Vampire Human/Vampire Relationship Vampire Turning Mind Manipulation POV First Person Blood Drinking Sick Character Non-Graphic Smut Gay Awakening Codependency Inspired by Interview With the Vampire POV Nick Carraway
Nick Carraway feels lost after the Great War. Jay Gatsby wants nothing to do with this new neighbor after an incident with his last one. But after Gatsby wrongfully draws in Nick for what would be a failed kill, Nick's mind is infected by the mystery...
more natsby

more natsby

F/F
M/M
G
Updated
11.04.2025
Fandom
The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
Characters
Nick Carraway/Jay Gatsby, Nick Carraway, Jay Gatsby, Jordan Baker (The Great Gatsby), Daisy Buchanan, Tom Buchanan, Jordan Baker/Daisy Buchanan
Tags
Angst Not Canon Compliant Religious Guilt Out of Character Internalized Homophobia Trauma Slow To Update Author Is Not Religious Author Is Sleep Deprived No Lesbians Die Somebody Lives/Not Everyone Dies Gay Nick Carraway
Based on a few headcanons from a tiktok mutual!!!!! i suck at writting im so sorry guysLook Gatsby didnt go around saying he was "Shellshocked" or whatever his psychatrist told him, those memories were shoved neatly into a box in his memories. Well u...
Forces Of Nature

Forces Of Nature

M/M
G
Updated
17.04.2025
Fandom
Game of Thrones (TV) Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling The Walking Dead (TV)
Characters
Nick Carraway/Jay Gatsby, Tom Buchanan, Rick Grimes, Doom Marine | Doom Slayer | Doomguy, Jesus Christ, Rick Grimes/Nick Carraway, Every relationship in the Galaxy, Atticus Finch/Arthur "Boo" Radley, Rick Grimes/Atticus Finch, Jon Snow/Rick Grimes, SpongeBob, Tony Hawk,
Tags
Fluff and Smut Alpha/Beta/Omega Dynamics Omega Verse Alternate Universe - Canada This is what happens when you share a Google Document amongst three people we are Not Okay Team Jesus Jesus Christ has a huge cock Mega Fluffy DOOM Slayer fucks the shit out of Jesus Christ This fic will make you cry your heart out Alternate Universe - Oklahoma
Jesus Christ has a lot of things to do, and the inhabitants of Earth are one of those things. Jesus Christ will absolutely fuck the shit out of everybody, and then he'll get fucked by DOOM Slayer.
meanwhile

meanwhile

F/F
M/M
G
Updated
12.04.2025
Fandom
The Great Gatsby (2013) Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
Characters
Nick Carraway/Jay Gatsby, Jordan Baker/Daisy Buchanan
Tags
Pining Fix-It of Sorts Drabble Screenplay/Script Format Missing Scene gays sure can pine Angsty sorta but not really cause idk how to format that nick and jordan are each other’s beards i wish i were heather type beat
What if Jordan and Nick did what they should have done and left the hotel early, and what if they had a chat on Gatsby’s beach?