Greta Gill/Carson Shaw FanFiction

Songbird (A Gretson x Bandstand 1940s AU)

Songbird (A Gretson x Bandstand 1940s AU)

F/F
G
Updated
11.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Carson Shaw/Charlie Shaw, Jo De Luca/Maybelle Fox, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw, Charlie Shaw (A League of Their Own TV 2022), Maybelle Fox, Vivienne Hughes, Jo De Luca, Lupe García, Shirley Cohen, Jess McCready,
Tags
Eventual Happy Ending Eventual Smut Eventual Romance Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder - PTSD Minor Character Death Period-Typical Homophobia Mental Health Issues Alcohol Abuse/Alcoholism Period-Typical Sexism Endgame Greta Gill/Carson Shaw Gretson Carson Shaw Needs a Hug
After almost four years as an Army nurse, Greta Gill returns home to a world that has both changed and stayed the same. Once home in Rockford, she is forced to make good on a promise which alters the trajectory of her life.
Love is a Rollercoaster

Love is a Rollercoaster

F/F
G
Updated
11.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw, Jo De Luca, Maxine "Max" Chapman
Tags
Alternate Universe - Modern Setting Angst Strangers to Lovers Birthday Gay Panic Best Friends Love at First Sight Tequila rollercoaster
When the prospect of turning 30 starts to get Carson down her best friend Max decides a trip to the themepark is the only solution to making her feel young again. However, between meeting Greta, the most beautiful woman she's ever seen and a broken r...
feedin' the plants

feedin' the plants

F/F
G
Updated
11.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Fern, Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw, Maybelle Fox, Jo De Luca, Terri Cobell
Tags
Alternate Universe - Modern Setting Meet-Cute Pets minor injury may and joey are Rat Moms
"Are you a robber? Burglar? Stealer of... Maybelle's seltzer water?"
and this was my prayer (save me from this terrible nightmare)

and this was my prayer (save me from this terrible nightmare)

F/F
G
Updated
11.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw
Tags
Gretson Thunderstorms just 2000 words of plotless fluff i love them your honor no beta we die like carsons heterosexuality
a storm over rockford reveals some personal history to greta
The Seven Boyfriends of Greta Gill

The Seven Boyfriends of Greta Gill

F/F
G
Updated
12.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw
Snapshots from the Twitter Social Media AU "The Seven Boyfriends of Greta Gill."
You're Every Woman in the World to me (you're my fantasy, you're my reality)

You're Every Woman in the World to me (you're my fantasy, you're my reality)

F/F
G
Updated
12.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw, Maxine "Max" Chapman, Charlie Shaw
Tags
Fluff song inspired plot no beta we die like carson's heterosexuality
It might seem weird but she feels something special about this woman. Maybe her hair? Her height? Her charisma? Her being hot and attractive when she didn’t like the candy from her drink? What?A little one-shot Gretson fic inspired by the song "Every...
Dreamt about you last night

Dreamt about you last night

F/F
G
Updated
12.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw
Tags
Smut Alternate Universe - Modern Setting Domestic Fluff i love them your honor saying i love you without saying the words
Greta dreams about Carson, and Carson can be such a tease.
Enough.

Enough.

F/F
G
Updated
12.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw
Tags
Sad Poetry Overthinking
Enough. Six letters. Six simple letters. But they weren’t simple, not at all.
Hold me close

Hold me close

F/F
G
Updated
12.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw
Tags
Fluff Alternate Universe - Modern Setting Hurt/Comfort Sickfic Carson Shaw Needs a Hug Domestic Greta Gill/Carson Shaw
Carson catches a cold, and Greta is there to hold her close.
Hold you close

Hold you close

F/F
G
Updated
12.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw
Tags
Fluff Alternate Universe - Modern Setting Mild Hurt/Comfort Greta Gill Needs A Hug Domestic Greta Gill/Carson Shaw
Greta has trouble sleeping through the night, and Carson just wants to help.
Hands Down

Hands Down

F/F
G
Updated
12.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw
Based on the song Hands Down by Dashboard Confessional
strangers (to me, not to you)

strangers (to me, not to you)

F/F
G
Updated
12.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022) Agent Carter (TV)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Peggy Carter, Angie Martinelli, Peggy Carter/Angie Martinelli, Peggy Carter & Angie Martinelli, Inferred Angie Martinelli/Greta Gill
Tags
vintage girlfriends crossover 1940s lesbians who call their girlfriends honey this is mostly agent carter rather than ALOTO but its definitely a crossover
“Oh thank God English, I was beginning to think...” she looks up from whatever she'd been reading, and her eyes dart between you and the other woman leaning against your door frame, her jaw slack with shock, “Greta?”Greta blinks and stutters out a re...
No Losses, Just WINS and TIES

No Losses, Just WINS and TIES

F/F
G
Updated
12.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw, Greta Gill & Carson Shaw
Tags
Fluff Love Confessions Falling In Love Pining Romance Love Self-Reflection Canon Lesbian Relationship Canon Lesbian Character Introspection Heartache Post-Canon
For Greta, the events on the porch were never supposed to happen. After pouring her heart out in a letter tucked into Carson’s suitcase, she was supposed to make a quick and quiet departure the next morning.That was until Carson had to “go get a thi...
The first time they...

The first time they...

F/F
G
Updated
12.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw, Maybelle Fox, Jo De Luca, Maxine "Max" Chapman
Tags
Smut Fluff Alternate Universe - Modern Setting Idiots in Love Baseball Firsts
A series of firsts. (And as always, be on the look out for edits because I am a mess. :p)
So, it's a date?

So, it's a date?

F/F
G
Updated
12.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw, Jo De Luca, Lupe García, Shirley Cohen, Jess McCready, Terri Cobell, Jo De Luca & Greta Gill, Esti González
Tags
Fluff and Smut Canon Compliant i love them your honor Top Greta Gill bedroom date Soft Greta Gill
“Are you asking me on a date?” Carson pressed her hands against Greta’s lower back, pulling her in close.“Do you want it to be a date, Carson?” Greta tried to sound cool, calm. She shifted her weight from one foot to the other, trying to ignore the w...
Feels like home

Feels like home

F/F
G
Updated
12.04.2025
Fandom
A League of Their Own (TV 2022)
Characters
Greta Gill/Carson Shaw, Greta Gill, Carson Shaw, Maybelle Fox, Jo De Luca, Lupe García, Shirley Cohen, Jess McCready, Maxine "Max" Chapman, Dove Porter, Meg (A League of Their Own TV 2022), Bertie Hart,
Tags
Alternate Universe - Modern Setting Slow Burn Angst with a Happy Ending Idiots in Love Team as Family Falling In Love Found Family Gretson University Strangers to Friends to Lovers Baseball Sports
Carson joins The Rockford Peaches baseball team. There they find a new family and fall in love.