Jay Gatsby/Nick Jonas FanFiction

Why Do You Lie When You Say You Don’t Love Me?

Why Do You Lie When You Say You Don’t Love Me?

Multi
G
Updated
24.04.2025
Fandom
Supernatural Fall Out Boy The Great Gatsby
Characters
Harry Potter, Sam Winchester, Dean Winchester, Draco Malfoy, Jay Gatsby, Pete Wentz, Castiel, Jay Gatsby/Nick Jonas, Nick Jonas/Dana Turner, Nick Jonas, Joe Jonas, Mitchie Torres,
Tags
:3 XD
Will Jatsby finally meet his true love who he’s been crushing on forever? Or will the Final Jam get in between them? Probably not because there’s nothing about the Final Jam in this. I swear it’s meant to be bad on purpose it’s a parody of bad fanfic...