You and ellie are in your bedroom, unpacking since you just moved in with her, you’ve been dating for about 6 months now, some would say it’s a bit too soon to be moving in but whatever, lesbians do tend to take things a bit fast. As you unpack you two are talking about the most random stuff, while ellie is looking through some junk in her closet so make room for your stuff, she finds a picture, “oh shit, i forgot i had this”, “hm?what is it lemme see” oh…it’s a picture of ellie with some girl “who’s that?” You say trying not to sound too jealous, i mean you knew ellie had girlfriends before you, this wasn’t news to you, but still it makes you a little angry to see someone holding your girlfriend so close.”careful babe, if i didn’t know any better i would think you were jealous” ellie replies with a small smirk forming on her face. “Okay just ignore my question, that’s fine too” ellie lets out a little chuckle at your reaction before answering “that’s kat, just a short fling from last year, we only dated like two months and we would fight like—all the time” oh…”come to think of it we’ve never fought before” you say, the genuine tone of your voice making ellie laugh a little “isn’t that good? Do you want to fight?” She said jokingly “no of course not” you replied rolling your eyes at the idea, “i mean yeah makeup sex is the hottest kind—but-“ you cut her off before she could finish that sentence “makeup sex?” You said almost embarrassed at your lack of knowledge and experience in this kind of thing, it’s not like you’d never dated anyone before ellie, you’ve had flings, even a few boyfriends before realizing you only liked girls, but ellie? Ellie was your first,as in she took your virginity.
“Yeah,makeup sex? You know after a fight making up through rough passionate sex” rough passionate sex…those words kept repeating in your head, you and ellie had sex but you wouldn’t describe it as ‘rough’, passionate? Yeah, but soft and loving and intimate and genuine. you were kinda sad that ellie was saying that the best kind of sex was a kind you two had never even had, and the thought of her with that girl kat ‘making up’ suddenly popped up in your head making you feel an irrational anger, ellie noticed your change of expression, but you didn’t let her enjoy having the upper hand for too long, she wanted makeup sex right? Well you needed a fight first, and that’s exactly what you were gonna give her.
”rough and passionate? Yeah i know what you mean” you said with a slight smirk that she could barely see, she fell silent for a moment before answering “what do you mean? I thought you said i was your first” was it working? Was your dumb petty plan actually working? “I mean yeah—but i said you were the first to make me cum, that doesn’t mean I’ve never made anyone cum before, why do you even care it’s not like you were a virgin when you met me?” You said trying to sound playful “yeah…i mean i don’t care, when did this even happen?”, “ummmm i dont know? Some random party? In the bathroom, she was my friend and she wanted to experiment and i was bored so…”, you watched as her expression slowly turned more serious, you knew ellie could get jealous and kinda possessive, but this, this was different, and you would be lying if you said it wasn’t super fucking hot.
”come on stop starring at me like i just killed your whole family” you said rolling your eyes at her and jumping up and off the bed “we gotta finish cleaning up before dina and jesse get here, remember?”, “of course i remember.” She was clearly angry, she wasn’t really the best at hiding her emotions from you, and you hear it in her voice.
when dina and jesse showed up, you ran to the door to greet them, giving them both warm hugs, you had all been friends for about a year and it was clear from the way all four of you acted that you were all pretty close, so when dina looked over to ellie sat on the couch looking not so happy, she guessed something had happened right before they showed up, the four of you sad down talking, ellie was talking to the both of them, trying to sound normal, and completely ignoring you. Which the couple quickly picked up on. In an attempt to break the growing tension between the two of you jesse said “hey uhhh ellie, do you have any guitar picks? Im trying to actually start using that guitar joel gave last year, it’s been collecting dust for a while” dina chimed in “yeah he’s getting real serious about it, he’s even taking online classes and everything its adorable” “oh come on dina” he said sounding kinda embarrassed by her comment. “Sure i have some in the bedroom, come on” the two got up and disappeared into the room leaving you and dina alone, her smile immediately dropped as she turned to you “okay…so are you gonna tell me what’s going on here?” She said sounding half amused and half concerned that something was actually going on, her concerns quickly melted away when a wide grin formed on your face “oh my god what did you do?” She said laughing at your expression, “ellie said the best kind of sex was makeup sex, so…i gave her a reason to be angry” you said with a mischievous smile on your face, “you bad bad girl, what exactly did you tell her?” She said, fully invested in this little story now, “oh nothing just a fake story about how i ate some girl out in a bathroom at a party” now you couldn’t hold your laugh back.
meanwhile jesse and ellie were in the bedroom, as she was frantically looking through her stuff to find the picks jesse broke the silence “soooo…what’s going on with you two?”, “nothing jesse it’s fine” she replied still looking through drawers growing more and more frustrated at how hard it was to find what she was looking for “ellie stop, you can give them to me later, for now just tell me what happened”, she gave up and sat on the bed in defeat her head in between her hands “i told her about how i used to have makeup sex with kat and she told me a story about her and some random girl, and i got angry at her for no reason like the asshole i am” jesse chuckled at her answer “what’s so funny about this?” She said a little annoyed at his reaction “oh god ellie, you’re so dramatic, you know she probably just said that to get you angry right?” actually, ellie hadn’t thought of that,at all…
”…you think so?”
“yes ellie, you brought up another girl to your girl? I would be angry too, clearly this was her revenge”
“she’s not really the jealous type though? I mean i think i dont know anymore” she groaned in defeat
“look at how you reacted when she told you, i mean how do you think she felt?”
”shit…you’re right, im an idiot” he laughed at her statement
“you really are, now get up they’re probably waiting for us”
when the two of them came out of the bedroom you gave dina a wink and went back to your ‘angry’ act, jesse walked up to dina and with a soft smile said “hey D, it’s getting kinda late and i have to wake up early tomorrow” , “yeah, you’re right” the two of them said goodbye and you closed the door behind them.
when you turned around, ellie was looking at you, still looking as furious as ever, what you didn’t know was that she caught up to your little act, and was gonna make you lose at your own game. Your stomach dropped a bit when you saw how she was looking at you, she knew it was an act but you didn’t, you really thought she was angry at you and it hurt like hell “Hey els, im sorry about what i said earlier” you said with a sad face, looking at her with those puppy eyes that she couldn’t resist, at that moment she almost broke and just kissed you right then and said ‘it’s all good baby im not mad you’ but she didn’t, she was gonna use this opportunity to get what she said she wanted earlier.
”oh you’re sorry?” She said mockingly “you can make it up to me”, and of course you were going to let her do whatever she wanted to you. Cuz while you were still concerned about her being mad at you, you were so fucking turned on right now. She walked up closer and leaned to whisper in your ear “you’re gonna go in the bedroom, and when i come in i better find you naked with your pretty legs spread wide open for me? Okay?” You nodded, fuck, you can’t say no to that can you? “Good girl” she said giving you chills all the way from your head to your toes.
when she walked in a few minutes later and found you exactly how she asked, she couldn’t help but stare, you always do what she wants, but this time, it was different.
she slid up on the bed, with her arms above your head and her knee in between your legs, almost touching you but just far enough to get you to wanna move up so you can get some sort of relief for the heat collecting inside you, ellie slowly guided her hand down your body towards your wet folds, rubbing circles with her thumb on your clit, getting your legs to shake with desire as you tried moving closer to her to get more friction, your attempt was stopped by ellie holding you down, you knew she was strong but this was just terrifying and so hot, the way she could hold all your weight down with just one arm, not because you were light but because she was just that fucking strong, i guess those muscles aren’t just for show? “you thought it would be that easy?”, “ellie please” you said pleading. “Sorry babe, that’s not gonna cut it, not after what pulled earlier”, “i said i was sorry ellie, please—please just touch me”, “saying sorry isn’t enough, you have to show me how sorry you are princess”
“okay,I’ll do whatever you want”, “that’s more like it,now you’re gonna get up on my lap and ride my thigh like it’s your job, and i might pay you by letting you cum”, “yes, whatever you want” the sound coming out of your mouth sounding more desperate than you expected.
as ellie turned around bringing you to sit on her lap, fully exposed while she was still fully dressed. you didn’t care though, you just wanted something anything, and she smelled so good right now and it made you crazy, you didn’t even realize just how bad you needed it until now. As you positioned yourself on her thigh and started moving slowly at first getting faster and more desperate as you felt an orgasm coming up, her hands on your hips guiding you “oh such a pretty girl, and you’re all mine right?”, “all yours,i promise”, “are you gonna come for me, pretty girl?”, finally you were so close “yes—yes oh my god im so close—im gonna come” you started moving faster the moans escaping your mouth getting louder and more erotic with each small move she made and just as you almost got there her grip on your hips suddenly tightened holding you in place, getting a desperate whimper out of you at her denying you yet another orgasm.
”again,i still don’t know if i forgive you
”baby please, im sorry, there is no girl, i lied ,im sorry” there. That’s just what she wanted to hear.
”ohhh my pretty girl, if you wanted me to fuck you so bad you just had to say so, you didn’t need to make up a lie about it” she picked you up putting you down on the bed almost throwing you, she got up and pulled something from the dresser facing the bed, you knew exactly what it was.
she put on the strap and walked over and held both your legs at her hips, you knew she had this but you’d never used it before, until now , “are you sure you’re ready for this?” She asked her tone suddenly a lot more gentle and soft, like how it usually was when you had sex, it was something you loved about her, how even when she had your legs shaking with pleasure she still managed to be so sweet and caring, always making sure you were comfortable and feeling loved and feeling good.
”yeah,I’m ready” you said barely able to string together a full sentence, after two failed orgasms you were desperate for this.
”okay honey” she slowly slid the full length of the toy inside you, only moving when you signaled her to, even when she was trying to be angry at you, she was still a big softy, only for you though.
she was going slow and deep at first, then when she could tell you were getting more comfortable she started speeding up, lifting you up slightly so she could hit that sweet spot, “OH—oh my god” you raised a hand to your mouth as you suddenly felt overwhelmed with pleasure, she took your hands off you mouth and held them in place “come on baby, i wanna hear your pretty voice” she quickened her pace going faster and faster as she could see you approaching your climax, “ellie, im gonna come” you said, not to warn her though, she already knew, it was more of a plea, a desperate attempt at getting her to hopefully let you come this time, you didn’t know if you could handle another denied orgasm. This time she looked at you with a look of such pure love and reassurance that she was gonna let you finally get what you wanted.
“Come on princess, come for me okay?”, “yes YES oh god please” you griped at her shoulders so hard you were sure it would leave a mark on her, but she didn’t care and neither did you, as you came she kept going in and out of you slowly helping you ride out your orgasm only pulling out when you looked completely ruined, collapsing on the bed when she pulled out of you, “that was incredible” you said your voice barely a whisper now, you were exhausted, face wet with tears and legs almost fully numb, she looked at you feeling almost guilty for the state you were in, even if she knew it was from pleasure, she still couldn’t help feeling the urge to protect and take care of you, “you did so good angel” she said before giving you a soft kiss on the forehead “lemme clean you up”.
after both of you were cleaned up ,the two of you laid on the bed, legs intertwined with your head on her chest, feeling her heartbeat always calmed you, “you know, i was never actually mad at you right?” , you let out a sigh of relief at what she just said “oh thank god,i was actually worried you know?” She laughed at your reply “awww baby im sorry for making you worry, you know i could never be too angry at you right?”,”yeah i know…” you said a soft smile forming on your face.
“You know i really liked that, but i love pur cheesy soft sex that leaves me feeling all fuzzy inside after,i don’t think i could handle this all the time, i mean shit i dont think I’ll be able to walk tomorrow”, she giggled at your comment “its okay hon,I’ll carry you around in my arms if i have to”.