Spider-Man: No Way Home but stupider

Marvel Cinematic Universe Marvel Spider-Man (Tom Holland Movies) Spider-Man: Spider-Verse (Sony Animated Movies) Spider-Man (Movies - Raimi) The Amazing Spider-Man (Movies - Webb) Marvel's Spider-Man (Insomniac Games Video Games)
G
Spider-Man: No Way Home but stupider
author

Question

Hey, this is a plan I have for when I get my hands on a physical copy of No Way Home, but first, I have a question.

As you can see, my MCU Redo Redo Spidey, which is based on my MCU Redo Spidey you saw in Civil War is part of this. My question is, who should be the actor for him.

The two I have in mind is either Andrew Garfield, because he played Spidey in 2012, when YFNHS-M would release, but it would mean he would be two Spideys, or Josh Keaton.

If you have any ideas, put them in the comments, but yeah. This will also impact my MCU Redo Redo as it will be the same Spidey. He would be 33 at the time when he gets sent to the actual MCU and start his Spider-Man journey at 15 in 2008, being 19 in YFNHS-M/2012.

 

This will be updated when the actor is chosen and deleted when I have a physical copy of No Way Home

 

Update: Not because an actor appeared, but because of a new Spidey appearance. I've decided Peter would be set up to exist in Fantastic Four, working as a high school-aged intern, being 16, of Reed. Reed would choose him due to his high grades and obscene intelligence, and question the spider bite, but Peter would brush it off. He'd work on an early plan for a piece of technology to send Impossible Man home that fails.