What should’ve happened

Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them (Movies)
F/M
M/M
G
What should’ve happened
Summary
What if Gellert didn’t mean to kill that student at dumstrang. What if during the duel between brothers the killing curse was thrown and Gellert actually saved Albus’ life and accidentally killed Ariana. What if Albus wasn’t an idiot and checked Gellerts’ wand. What if they managed to peacefully merge muggles and wizards. What if they found Theseus in Paris after the duel and adopted him, then later they found Newt being raised by hippogriffs when he was a baby and adopted him. Let’s see how their story should’ve gone shall we.
All Chapters Forward

Chapter 5

Albus and Gellert quickly went upstairs when they got to the bagshot residence. Albus noticed that it was unusually quiet which meant Bathilda had gone out which was good.

Gellert puts up a strong silencing ward and locks the door, pushing Albus against it and kissing him. “Before you even ask, yes the curtains are closed” he mumbles against his lips then moves to kiss down his neck. Humming when Albus puts his hands in Gellerts hair, tugging a bit

Albus was already gasping and leaning his head back while Gellert kissed his neck “Merlin, how can you make me like this with only a few kisses” he mumbles and gasps again as he’s picked up, wrapping his legs around Gellerts waist and looking at him.

Gellert brings him to the bed and lays him on it “if you think that’s good you’re in for a rough couple of hours” he charms Albus’ clothes off and and kisses him again. Pulling him closer to him and kissing along his jaw, biting his ear “how far have you gone with another boy before” he whispers

Albus gasps at the bite to his ear and moans a bit, quietly “o-only fingering..” he doesn’t know why he’s embarrassed by that, maybe because Gellert seems so experienced. He moans again when he feels a rough grind of cloth on the bare skin of his ass as Gellert hums, feeling him smirk against his neck.

“Good” Gellert murmurs and continues kisses down his body, sucking marks that Albus’ clothes could hide. He takes his own clothes off getting impatient and his trousers getting uncomfortable. Gellert listens as he tests out sucking on one of Albus’ nipples, making a content noise and sucking more when his lover gives a muffled moan; wanting to tear more of those delicious noises from Albus without him muffling them. “We have a silencing charm you don’t need to hold back” he whispers, his accent noticeably thicker now in the throes of need, and goes back to sucking and nibbling on the now perked nubs in front of him. His hands wander down, already coated in an oil from a charm, and grabs the other teens dick; slowly jerking him. Working him up slowly to drag this out as long as he can, wanting to hear Albus beg for him

Albus was still biting his lip to hold back his moans, embarrassed by how high his voice sounded muffled, until Gellert started to give him a handjob and he couldn't help but let a moan slide through. Albus quickly covered his mouth to muffle more moans coming out but that didn’t last long before his hands were pulled away by an invisible force and pinned next to his head. When he looks down he sees mismatched eyes staring intently at him and Albus moans again and looks away and a particularly tight squeeze to his dick. He couldn’t believe how easily and quickly Gellert could find his weak spots, it’s like he was naturally inclined to his body.

Gellert smirks and stops sucking on Albus’ nipples, as much enjoyed watching Albus as he sucked and bit his perk and dusty pink nipples; He wanted to move things along now and started to kiss down his body again. As he was still Jerking Albus off, speeding up his hand just a bit but not by a lot, he starts kissing around his groin and hums at the smoothness “is this natural or just a shaving spell in anticipation?” He mumbles again the joint between Albus’ hip and thigh, looking at the other in question, showing he wasn’t just talking to himself.

Albus was too caught up in the feeling of Gellerts mouth being so close to his dick but never touching and still giving him such intense pleasure he almost missed the question that he was asked. He looks at the other Wizard and takes a second to answer without sounding needy, “I don’t grow much hair other than my face and head” he moans at the end of the sentence as Gellert nips the sensitive skin of his groin. He closes his eyes as Gellert decides to stop teasing him and gently sucks on the head of his dick, playing with the slit with his tongue, and massaging his balls. He can’t help the moans that escape his mouth, getting higher with every inch more of his dick Gellert sucks in. Albus gasps and tries to move his hands again as Gellert takes in all of him without a single gag, or stop to get his bearings.

Gellert releases the hold he had on his lover's hands and lets him hold his hair, feeling Albus tug in his hair. He looks up at the 18 year old and sucks around him, giving a gentle but firm squeeze to his balls. He’s set on making this something he’ll never forget. He smirks around his snack as Albus moans again and roughly pulls his hair, Gellert slicks up his free hand again and circles a finger around Albus’ right hole and pulls off for a second “Mm, my you don’t use this often do you?” He smirks and goes back to sucking his dick before he could answer.

Albus couldn’t believe all the pleasure he was in and it was taking everything in his being not to curl around Gellerts head and just keep him there. He had his eyes closed while moaning, and tried to answer Gellerts question “n-not much, T-TIME…alone” his hips jerk as Gellert sucks harder and his finger pushes into his hole. Albus was already a mess and so close, his moans got higher the closer he got to the edge. He was almost about to cum when Gellert suddenly pulled away and pulled his finger out. Albus gasps and makes a frustrated noise “Hey!”

Gellert smirks and kisses him “patience,” he whispers and kisses to his ear “and it might do you good to cast a translator spell.” He goes back to kissing his neck and goes back to push two slick fingers in his hole, thrusting and stretching them inside. Gellert listened to the noises Albus was making and smirks against his neck “what do you want kleiner Phönix*” he hears Albus gasp then moan as he finds that patch of nerves inside him as he adds a third finger.

Gellert goes on for a few more minutes, thrusting his fingers against Albus’ prostate until he pulls away when the other is close to orgasm again. “Ich warte*” he says teasingly and sits up, pulling Albus’ hips against his own “what do you say?” He tilts his head watching Albus trying to gather his thoughts.

Albus was starting to get upset that Gellert kept pulling away from him everytime he got close, putting his arms around the others shoulders, catching his breath a bit. He understood a bit of German enough to understand what he said but not what he called him “Gellert I want you, please” he tried to pull him closer to kiss him.

Gellert leans down, kissing him “then relax kleiner Phönix” He murmurs against Albus’ lips and sits up a bit to be able to see himself sink into the other teen. He casts the spell again to cover his own dick in that fragrant oil and slowly pushes into Albus. Taking note of him tensing and even though it felt heavenly to him he stopped about halfway in and looked at Albus “open your eyes Albus.”

Albus had squeezed his eyes shut and bit his lip when Gellert started to push in, holding back the pain he felt. ‘Why is it this painful, should it be?’ he wondered to himself before he noticed that Gellert had stopped and was talking to him. He opens his eyes and looks at Gellert “y-yes?” He says quietly he looks at him “why did you stop moving?”

Gellert was rubbing his hand along Albus’ thigh “Because you need to relax, and you aren’t relaxing” he moves his hands and massages along his pelvic bone “as much as you feel incredibly wondrous to me, you aren’t enjoying yourself.” He watches as Albus looks back at him, starting to relax and slowly pushes the rest of the way in and leans over him.

Albus holds onto Gellert again, feeling him tense, trying not to move. The feeling of him bottoming out was still painful but not nearly as much as when he first pushed in “you haven’t done this before either?” Albus looked at him again, Gellerts face was pinched and he had his eyes closed.

Gellert was forcing himself not to move for Albus’ sake, he knew moving immediately would be painful for him. After all, he normally just took what he wanted, only caring for his previous lover's pleasure when he wanted too. But with Albus he wanted every move he made to pleasure the other boy, Gellert wanted him to scream his name in pleasure not pain, he wanted Albus to replace Merlin’s name with his own during exclamations. He looks at Albus after he asks a question “I have, I just never had to wait to move but you can tell me when you’re ready for me to move.”

They sat like that for a couple of minutes; Albus with his arms and legs wrapped around Gellert, flushed a deep pink from the heat they created in the room, and Gellert with his knees under Albus’ ass to lift it, his arms caging in the others head, and most importantly with Albus impaled on his dick. Albus soon tested moving his hips in a small circle and moans when it felt amazing. Gellert takes that as his permission to start thrusting and starts at a slow pace, essentially just rolling his hips in a way to reach deep but still being slow and gentle on Albus’ body.

Albus starts moaning again as Gellert moves, Gellert obviously knew what he was doing to Albus. He kisses Gellert again as he moves and moans into his mouth as he feels him speed up just a bit. He knew he was going slow because of him but this was just a bit too slow for him “f-faster” he moaned into Gellerts mouth. His moans are swallowed by another kiss as Gellert speeds up but uses the same force behind his thrusts. Albus felt like he was floating in a cauldron of Amortentia; he felt amazing, like nothing could tear them apart.

Gellert keeps thrusting like that for a while until he gets bored with the pace. Picking one of Albus’ legs off his hip and moving it to his shoulder, he leans down again and raises on his knees more to reach deeper and use more force in his thrusts, still going the same speed. This causes Albus’ moans to get higher and louder, losing the ability to form more words than ‘more’ and ‘Gellert’. Gellert smirks, finding out what let him achieve his goal of making Albus chant his name, now just go find that one spot that would make him scream his name like a charm.

Gellert keeps that speed and force, changing how deep he thrusts to find Albus’ prostate. It takes a couple of minutes but he knows he found it when the smaller boy almost screams and his eyes look like they rolled back. He keeps thrusting into that spot relishing in Albus chanting his name like he’s praying “hangosabb” Gellert pants in his ear.

Albus couldn’t stop moaning, or control his voice. His mind had gone blank the second Gellert found his prostate and all he could focus on was him. He was almost screaming again when he heard Gellert say something in Hungarian but couldn’t process it until Gellert said it louder “hangosabb!” He heard him demand in his ear and Albus almost screams as he cums “Gellert!” He couldn’t help the shaking as he came, he never had felt this intense of a climax before, he didn’t even know he could cum without touching himself just a bit.

Gellert keeps thrusting through Albus’ orgasm and groans as he feels the others' magic explode around them, knocking things off shelves and his desk. He soon cums after him from all the sensations around him from Albus’ magic washing over him to his hole pulsating around him, he couldn’t hold back any longer. He holds onto Albus for a few minutes, kissing his knee occasionally since it was right next to his face.

After a bit and them both calming down a little more Gellert pulls out and lays down next to the red head. He pulls him close and lifts the blankets over them, taking down the silencing ward “by Merlin” he mumbles, looking at the ceiling. He’s never felt that instense during sex, and he’s definitely never has cum that close after a lover of his.

Albus opens his eyes when Gellert mumbles, not even noticing that he closed them in the first place. “That was..” he licks his lips, noticing that they were dry, most likely from all his screaming and moaning. Gellert nods and looks at him kissing him deeply

“das werden wir auf jeden Fall wiederholen*” He says, not noticing that he slipped into speaking in German. Albus smiles a bit “I know you taught me some German and Hungarian but I don’t know that much. All I understood was repeat.” He yawns after his sentence

Gellert hums and takes a second to speak again “apologies, I said that we will definitely repeat that.” He checks the time and hums “an hour and a half, not bad for your first time kleiner Phönix” he pulls him closer “you should stay the night though, after that buzz of your orgasm wears off you’ll probably be sore”.

Albus gladly moves closer to Gellert when the other pulls him closer, “you know I can’t” he closes his eyes “my siblings..”

“You’re siblings should be fine for one night, you are an adult you deserve time away from them” he murmurs quietly noticing the other falling asleep “go to sleep kleiner Phönix, I’ll awake you for dinner”

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

When Albus awoke again he took awhile to wake up, opposed to how he usually woke up which was quickly. He quickly noticed he was in a different position that when he fell asleep and his body hurt. He opens his eyes and notices he was in a tub, probably charmed to keep hot, and Albus also felt that he was laying against a chest. He quickly goes go move before hands around his waist hold him down

Gellert had moved them to the bath to clean them up while Albus was asleep and thought it would be better for him to lay here with him when he woke up to lessen the pain he would most likely be in since he didn’t have any healing potions in his room at the moment. “Albus it’s me” he says when he feels the other trying to pull away, “it’s only me”. He lets the tiger relax against him again “good evening, kleiner Phönix” he kisses his neck “how did you sleep?”

Albus relaxes when he realizes he’s still with Gellert and leans his head to the side as the other kisses his neck. “It was good, it took me a bit to wake up which is what startled me” he looks at him “how long have we been in here?”

Gellert hums and waves a floating tea set over “an hour at most, how are you feeling” he takes a cup of self pouring tea and another for Albus, handing it to him.

Albus takes the tea and sips from it before putting more sugar in it, laughing when he sees Gellerts face from the corner of his eye “what? I like sweets. And I’m sore..really sore.” He drinks his tea and lays his head on his chest “this tub is bigger than it should be for this bathroom” he thinks out loud to himself.

Gellert let’s Albus lay his head down and rest his chin on his “magic Albus, and you’ll be sore for a bit. I do not have any healing potions in my room and I doubted you wanted my aunt barging up here wondering why I would need a healing potion when I’m perfectly fine..” he trails off while looking at the water, a vision appearing, Albus looking older shaking hands with a woman in a crown and sash Gellert next to him.

Albus nods then notices Gellert looking at the water intently “Gellert…Gel!” He waves his hand in front of the others face until he snaps out of his trance. He got concerned something happened and placed his cup back on the tray, turning back to his..boyfriend?…to check up on him. His hand goes to check his forehead when it’s grabbed by a paler but thicker hand. “What happened, are you ok you just..well I don’t know what happened it looked like you just left.”

Gellert sighs at Albus’ worry and kisses his wrist “I am fine, it just happens sometimes.” He can tell Albus doesn’t buy his half truth and pulls him in for a kiss.

Albus sinks into the kiss before pulling away “no, not working, what happ…” he looks at the water again as if figuring out a puzzle and looks back up “you’re a seer aren’t you..?” Albus looks amazed, seers are incredibly rare and they usually brag about being one so it’s amazing Gellert didn’t tell him yet.

Gellert leans his head back “yes I am, and no I don’t like to brag about it because then everyone wants to know they’re future, and they don’t want to use cards or tea because that’s ‘not real fortune telling’. When I can’t control my visions AND cards along with tea are very base forms which can work for normal wizards and witches but only occasionally are true unless performed by a true seer” he gives a little speech getting more irritated as he talks and the tea set cracks “it’s annoying and a burden. When you’re trying to enjoy something for one and all of a sudden you get a vision of a war or a man that looks like a snake killing non-magic born, and I don’t mean he looks like a liar I mean he looks like an actual snake” he looks at Albus again.

Albus puts his hands on Gellerts face “I know you think it’s a burden and I know why it’s annoying, I always wondered why you so easily hid your thoughts and now I know it’s because you’re probably always thinking about your visions. But they’re a gift too, you have to have had some good ones right?” He rests his forehead on Gellerts trying to calm him down.

Gellert looks at his eyes and lays his own hands over Albus’. He’s the first person to understand, and instead of insisting that he’s stupid for thinking it a burden explains why he thinks it’s a gift. And understands what he always has to go through. He can see that in the others eyes. Gellert closes his eyes “recently they’ve been good..since I met you you seem to be the focus of them” he kisses him “like earlier when we were kissing under the tree, I saw that yesterday afternoon after you left for your house. I thought it was just my imagination since it wasn’t in a window or reflective surface like they usually are, until I used some tarot cards and it showed The Lovers and Justice combined” he looks at Albus and notes the confused look on his face “you didn’t take divination for the easy credit did you..did your school have divination?”

Albus smiles and shakes his head “no I didn’t take Divination, and yes Hogwarts did have it I just was more interested in astronomy. Since I also think divination is asinine for most,” Albus kisses Gellert again “so no I don’t know what those cards mean, and I honestly didn’t take you for someone to use Tarot cards”

Gellert pulls him closer “it was my first time using them somewhat seriously; but The Lovers in of itself means you are at a crossroads, usually romantically, and are having a difficult time choosing. Though recently the meaning had changed to people believing it means you’ve found your soulmate.” He puts his finger over Albus’ mouth so he doesn’t interrupt “Justice is relatively straightforward to its name; since Solomon it’s been connected to the idea of humane and fair-minded treatment of others. It is also connected to moral sensitivity, empathy, compassion and fairness” he takes his hand away from Albus’ mouth “now you can talk kleiner Phönix”.

Albus listened to Gellert his kind racing a mile a minute “how does that point to me, other than the new meaning for Lovers? And why do you keep calling me that?” He could make out Phoenix because they sound similar and each language but couldn’t make out the first word.

Gellert hums and waves over two towels “well because at first I didn’t understand how you made me feel, hence cross roads, and if you haven’t noticed I lack empathy for most things so that had to come from somewhere.” He helps Albus get out and wraps him in a towel, drying himself off and putting the towel around his waist “and for the nickname it is because you are my little phoenix” he takes a strand of Albus’ hair and kisses it

Albus blushes and follows him back to the room limping a bit “you have empathy it’s just not..as open as most people” he sits on the bed, on his side and catches the clothes tossed at him “these aren’t mine”

“Yours are dirty” Gellert says and puts his own clothes on “I haven’t washed them yet” he sits with him and puts the shirt around his shoulders, pretending he couldn’t clean them with a snap of his fingers easily.

Albus smiles a bit and puts the shirt on, looking at his body in it “you just want to see how I look in your clothes” he buttons it and laughs when he’s pushed to the bed and kissed “and I’m guessing I look good”

“You would look good in anything” Gellert kisses him again wraps Albus’ legs around him, making a discontented noise when Albus pulls his mouth away “I was doing something Albus”

“I know but this is a serious question” he lays his head back and looks at him “you’ll tell me when you have a vision right? Good or bad. So you don’t have to keep it to yourself anymore”

Gellert looks at him for a second then sits up “truly I’ve done nothing to deserve you Albus Dumbledore”

Albus sits up and wraps his arms around him again “it’s Albus Percival Wolfric Brian Dumbledore good sir” he smiles and laughs a bit

“I am never using your full name” Gellert fixes Albus’ hair “it’s unnecessarily long” he looks up from a knock on the door “yes aunt” he massages his finger against Albus’ wrist.

Gellert listens as his aunt talks “it’s Wednesday Gellert I expect you down for dinner in 10 minutes, I assume Albus is in there too so he can join us if he pleases”.

Gellert hums “alright” he looks at Albus “join us for dinner?” He cleans Albus’ clothes and gives them to him.

Albus stands up to put them back on “I thought you ate up in your room” he fixes his shirt and his hair, looking as the other gets up.

Gellert buttons his shirt “everyday but Wednesday I do, part of the rules for my housing”. He glares at the door at the knock again “yes we’re coming aunt, we’re just finishing up a conversation so if you will please leave us alone.”

~~~~~~~

When Albus gets home it was just Aberforth up “I had dinner at the ms.Bagshots” he looks at his brother “stop glaring, you look like mother after you would sneak out and get caught”.

“You shouldn’t spend so much time around Grindelwald, one might get ideas..” he gets up and goes upstairs.

“Stop it Aberforth, you aren’t father or mother stop acting like it. And you say it as if mother didn’t know” he goes to his room “I don’t know what your problem is”.

Forward
Sign in to leave a review.