It has been established on Tumblr that O’Knutzy are Swifties. It is also known that Logan lives a lot in his own head. When Midnights comes out, he can’t help but feel that Bejeweled is how Finn must have felt about their situationship before they were officially together. So, of course he has a little fun playing with the lyrics as he mentally tortures himself about possibly having mentally tortured Finn. So, picture Logan in the shower, singing out random snatches (in bold) of these lyrics, with a very confused Leo and Finn overhearing the snippets as they do important stuff in the kitchen (and wishing they could join him in the shower):
“Baby ‘Lo, I think I've been a little too kind
Didn't notice you skating all over my peace of mind
In the boots I gave you as a present
Puttin' someone first only works when you're in their first line
And by the way, I'm gonna play tonight
Best believe I'm still bejeweled
When I walk in the rink
I can still make the whole place shiver
And when I meet the team
They ask, "Can you be mean?"
I can still say, "I don't remember"
Familiarity breeds contempt
Don't put me in the basement
When I want to be on the roof of your heart
Diamonds in my eyes
I skate real, I skate on ice
Nice
They only just got him singing the proper words to Blank Space a week ago.
--
Meanwhile, Finn, in his first year with the Lions, adopted Bulletproof as his bop, because he missed hearing Logan call him Roux, and if this was all he could get, then by d*mn he was going to take it. Plus, that song slams.
Finn wants to make one of La Roux’s outfits his next Hallowe’en costume, but he also doesn’t want Logan to listen to the song too closely. He doesn’t want Logan to start having a conversation with the-Finn-in-Logan’s-brain about why Finn identified so strongly with the song.