Truth or Dare - Poly!Marauders/fem!reader
Tonight was girls night and you were spending the evening with Lily, Marlene, Dorcas, Alice and Mary in the girls dorm.
At the moment, all of you were playing truth and dare.
It was your turn as Marlene asked, “Truth or dare?”
You thought for a moment, before answering, “Dare.”
She looked to the others before turning to you, smirking and giving you your dare, “I dare you to go to your crush and kiss them.”
You sat silently thinking through your options before blurting without thinking, “what if I have more than one crush?”
You wish you could’ve taken it back in that moment, but Lily responded before you had a chance to take it back, “give each of them a kiss.”
You nodded silently. You went to the common room, knowing that more than likely they’d be there or in their dorm.
You weren’t sure whether you should feel grateful that they were in the common room or not. You were feeling nervous and scared. Your crushes were your three best friends; James Potter, Sirius Black and Remus Lupin.
“Go on,” you heard from behind you. You didn’t even know who it was that said it, but you moved toward the guys.
When you were close, you quietly said, “hi guys.”
James looked up first, “hey, I thought it was girls night tonight.”
You scratched the back of your head slightly as Remus and Sirius looked at you and you nodded sitting next to James, “yeah, it is. We were playing truth or dare, which is why I’m here. It’s my turn and I chose dare.”
Remus nodded. “Then what’s the dare?”
You looked down, “I have to kiss my crushes.”
“You have more than one, pretty thing?” Sirius asked.
“Yes,” you blushed as you looked between them. “All three of you.” You paused but immediately added, “I don’t want to make things weird between us though. If you don’t like me like that, that’s fine. We can stay friends. I’m sure-”
You got cut off by Sirius sitting down beside you, taking your hand and James taking your other hand.
James cupped your cheek, getting you to face him as you closed your eyes and leaned into it.
Next thing you knew, you felt his lips on yours, kissing you. It was the most beautiful thing you’d ever felt.
When he pulled back, he gave you one more quick kiss before whispering, “it won’t ruin anything, I swear. It’ll just make it better.”
Before you had a chance to ponder that, you turned to find Remus kneeling in front of you. He sat up and you leaned down slightly to give him a kiss, before you moved back.
Sirius immediately got your attention, by kissing your cheek. You turned to him and you let him lead the kiss, knowing that you would be safe with him, just as you would with James or Remus. They would only protect you; never hurt you.
“Would you like to be with us?” Remus asked.
“Really?”
“Yes,” Remus stood up, looking down at you.
“I’d love that. I’d love to be yours.”
“Perfect, lovely,” James responded, giving you another quick kiss. “Would you like to go back to your game? Or would you prefer to spend some time with your new boyfriends?”
“Be with all of you,” was your quick response. “Let me tell them and we can go.”
James took your hand, “let me come with you.”
You nodded, both of you getting up and going to the stairs.
You saw the girls watching you as you came over. “Thank you for the dare. It made us closer.” You looked up at James who was giving one of his trademark smirks until he looked down at you. “However, I won’t be joining the game again. I’m going to spend time with my new boyfriends.”
With that, the two of you went up to their dorm with Remus and Sirius following. It was definitely going to be a good night.