A Marauder’s Fallacy

Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling
F/M
G
A Marauder’s Fallacy
Summary
What if James had taken a more proactive role when the Potters went into hiding? What if his fellow Marauders were mostly absent and he was left alone to brainstorm with nothing but Comedy Satire for inspiration?Follow James Potter's way of protecting his family by adding his dumb luck to Lily's pure love to defeat Voldemort and watch the origin of Harry’s famed “Potter Luck”.A What-if short story with slice-of-life, angst and some fluffy elements.
Note
Since English is neither my first nor my second language, I hope you can manage to get through my first attempt at authoring fanfiction without feeling the urge to scratch your eyes out. Should you come across any obvious and offending grammar or spelling mistakes that make your eyes water, feel free to comment so I can correct them.I did try to be mindful of using only British English. However, as our media is heavily influenced by American English, I wouldn’t rule out the possibility that one or two Americanisms have found their way into the story. If you do find anything, again feel free to comment so I can make the appropriate changes.To not disrupt your reading experience I will limit the author notes to this one preceding the first chapter.And last but not least the mandatory declaration that I unfortunately do not own anything created by J.K. Rowling or Warner Bros Entertainment. Every character and setting you may recognize as well as the Potterverse belong to J.K.Rowling. I am not making any money from writing or publishing this story.
All Chapters Forward

Chapter 4

On Halloween morning 1981 James Potter was a nervous wreck. Pulling his Arithmancy work back out, he scribbled furiously on the parchment, calculating the most probable time of day for an attack. 

 

This time the result was rather obvious. Naturally a Dark Lord wouldn't attack during the day. Throwing his quill to the side, he got up to pace. 

 

James stared with unseeing eyes out the window, when Lily finally found him in the study. “James? What are you doing in here? Come on, I've just fed Harry and made us some lunch.” 

 

He couldn’t help but smile at the care his wife displayed. He'd been so happy when she finally responded to his advances. Having her by his side still felt too good to be true at times. He loved her so much. 

 

“Coming,” he assured her, following his two favourite people (besides Sirius) into the dining room. Lily huffed a laugh and adjusted her hold on little Harry, who was glancing happily over her shoulder at him. 

 

“Hello mate, had a nice meal already?”, he asked his son with a grin. That got him a proud nod in return. “Paddy,” his son exclaimed with enthusiasm while he waved his stuffed dog about. 

 

Laughing, James scooped Harry out of Lily's arms and propped him securely on his side. “Now, I don't think little Paddy needs much food, Harry. Even though big Padfoot loves to eat a lot.” 

 

Lily snorted. “Don't give him ideas, James,” she chided playfully, “I don't want him pushing everything he doesn't like over to Sirius.” Her eyes gleamed with mirth, though. 

 

He could just imagine how happy Sirius would be if he'd be drowning in peas or carrots every time he was visiting in the future. 

 

“Pad?” Harry asked with big wondering eyes. Lily's eyes. His heart melted. 

 

“Padfoot is very busy right now,” he answered carefully while they settled around the table. “I'm sure he'll come visit you as soon as he can though. I miss that shaggy dog, too,” he continued with an encouraging smile. 

 

“Sirius still has to see him on his broom, Lily. That's almost a betrayal to the Quidditch community,” he complained dramatically. 

 

“I sent him a picture and don't you forget who bought that toy broomstick in the first place,” Lily replied, rolling her eyes. “You know just as well as I do how many missions the Order has right now. And Sirius is an Auror trainee, too.” 

 

The last part was said with a sympathetic wince. James and Sirius had originally planned to apply for the Auror Trainee Program together, but the prophecy had made that course of action infeasible. He simply couldn't leave his family alone. They all had targets on their heads. 

 

Sighing, he ran a hand through his hair. A nervous habit he still hadn't given up. James needed to tell Lily about the Felix Felices potion. He didn’t want to start this conversation, because it made the possibility of something happening today too real for comfort. 

 

If they wanted the advantage the potion could grant them, though, they needed to take it before it got dark. Just to be sure. His grip on Harry tightened a bit and he hugged his son closer to his chest. 

 

“What's wrong James? You've been acting weird since breakfast today,” Lily asked him worriedly. Her whole being expressed concern, making him feel even worse for what he wanted to address. 

 

“Lils…,” he started hesitantly, “Lily-Flower, I need to tell you something.” 

Forward
Sign in to leave a review.